LEGAL NOTE: False implication in the POCSO case

LEGAL NOTE: False implication in the POCSO case

Dr. Anthony Raju, Advocate Supreme Court

If falsely implicated in a Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) case in India, the accused has legal remedies to challenge the charges and seek compensation for malicious prosecution. The POCSO Act itself includes provisions to penalize false complaints. 

Legal strategies for the accused

Gather evidence: Work with your legal counsel to collect strong evidence that proves your innocence, the falsehood of the complaint, or a malicious motive on the part of the complainant. This can include CCTV footage, digital records, witness testimonies, and expert medical reports.

Obtain the First Information Report (FIR): Get a copy of the FIR from the police to understand the specific allegations against you.

Seek bail: As many POCSO offenses are non-bailable, a court’s discretion is necessary to grant bail. You can file a bail application and argue that the allegations lack merit.

Challenge the FIR: You can file a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) with the High Court to have the false or frivolous case quashed.

File a counter-complaint: You can file a counter-FIR against the malicious accuser under Section 182 (false information) and Section 211 (false charge of an offense) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).

Cross-examine witnesses: During the trial, your lawyer can firmly cross-examine the complainant and other witnesses to highlight any inconsistencies in their testimony.

Present your defense: The prosecution bears the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Your defense should focus on disproving their case and establishing your innocence. 

Reasons for false implication

False POCSO cases often arise from motives other than seeking justice. Common scenarios include: 

Marital and custody disputes: A false accusation can be used by one parent to gain an advantage in a divorce or child custody battle.

Personal enmity or grudges: False allegations can be lodged to defame, humiliate, or take revenge on another person.

Financial extortion: The threat of a serious POCSO charge can be used to demand money from the accused.

Property disputes: Accusations may be fabricated in an attempt to coerce a party into settling a land or property dispute. 

Penalties for false complaints

Section 22 of the POCSO Act addresses penalties for making a false complaint.

For malicious intent: If an adult makes a false complaint to humiliate, extort, or threaten someone, they can face imprisonment for up to six months and/or a fine.

False complaint against a child: An adult who knowingly makes a false complaint against a child can be punished with imprisonment for up to one year and/or a fine.

Protection for children: No punishment is imposed on a child who makes a false complaint or provides false information. 

Consequences for the falsely accused

A false accusation under POCSO can have severe consequences for the accused, even if they are ultimately acquitted. 

Immediate arrest: A complaint can lead to immediate arrest, subjecting the individual to incarceration.

Social stigma: The public perception of guilt in these cases can cause permanent social stigma, humiliation, and ostracization.

Mental trauma: The accused and their family suffer severe mental agony, trauma, and emotional distress.

Reputation damage: An individual’s reputation and career can be irreparably damaged. 

Compensation for wrongful implication

Courts recognize the severe impact of false accusations and can order compensation for the wrongfully accused. 

Damages: Courts have awarded damages to compensate for illegal detention, mental agony, and loss of reputation.

Court action: Courts have ordered investigations and legal action under Section 22 of POCSO against those who file malicious false cases.

Existing laws: Section 211 of the IPC covers compensation for malicious prosecution, although further legislation may be needed to ensure fair disbursement.  

For legal help, Connect 8588872001  #Pocso #humanrightscommission

Disclaimer
This note is intended for general legal awareness only and does not constitute legal advice. It highlights that instances of false implication under the POCSO Act have been recognized by various courts in India, and the law provides remedies for those wrongfully accused. Every case depends on its own facts and circumstances. For specific advice and defense strategy, individuals are strongly advised to consult a qualified legal professional.

By admin